I Love You Both

Play trailer

2:11

I Love You Both

2017

1h 30m

Comedy

Drama

LGBTQ+

Play Trailer

Watchlist

Watchlist

Tomatometer

Popcornmeter

Tomatometer

4 Reviews

54%

Popcornmeter

100+ Ratings

Krystal and her twin brother have been codependent their entire lives, still living together in their late 20s in a one-bedroom house. When they both meet and start dating the same guy, they remain in denial about the situation until he picks only one of them, forcing them to confront that they can no longer live the same life. With nowhere to turn for advice, the twins are finally forced to look within for answers.

Watch on Fandango

Stream Now

Gary Goldstein

Los Angeles Times

Jun 8, 2017

Although "I Love You Both" never quite pays off on its provocative set-up, it proves to be a funny and endearingly quirky comedy about siblings, love and loyalty.

Go to Full Review

Alexander Ryll

Gay Essential

Sep 15, 2019

3.5/5

Imagine meeting a fun and flirtatious 20-something named Andy. He's charming, handsome, has great taste in music. Now imagine finding yourself in a love triangle with Andy...and your twin sibling.

Go to Full Review

Martha K. Baker

KDHX (St. Louis)

Aug 29, 2017

[I Love You Both] is unpredictable and delightful, an amuse bouche.

Go to Full Review

Dan Schindel

Paste Magazine

Jun 15, 2017

5.8/10

Even at 90 minutes, I Love You Both feels padded.

Go to Full Review

Read all reviews

Gi S

@Gistevenn Feb 14, 2026

Funny, interesting story, good acting, i was gonna give it 3 1\2* but for the ending. I hate when a movie ends abruptly like that without going anywhere.

See more

Jan 12, 2020

It was a good movie. But felt the ending was anticlimactic.to be honest i thought that because Andy seemed to be into both he would end up with both. Given how close the relationship they had as sibling it would have been a better ending.though i get why not since its not as acceptable these days to have a poly relationship. But i could feel they would have been able to share andy because he made time for both and had good chemistry when all 3 together or when he was with one independently. But again. Good movie. Just incomplete ending.

See more

Dec 8, 2017

It's like a Chekhov play (a long look at people who go nowhere and do nothing) only shorter without feeling like it. I hate saying that because I loved the cast and would have enjoyed seeing any of them have 3 minutes of meaningful dialogue.

See more

Oct 3, 2017

strange movie. twins, one gay are attracted to the same guy, andy (lucas neff) they meet at a party. andy is bisexual and seems attracted to both and the twins try to figure out which he is sexually attracted to. the quirky characters don't seem very realistic and the ending is unsatisfying. watchable , but nothing noteworthy.

See more

Jun 30, 2017

It's somewhat slow-paced, but the tempo works. The jokes are realistic and land well. This movie isn't for everybody, but if you want that sort of thing Marvel should have some new "crowd-pleasers" in the summer.

See more

Jun 9, 2017

Watched this on Amazon Prime today. I enjoyed the quirky characters and the story line reminded me of some of my favorite movies in nineteen-ninties I'd go see at the theaters in Dupont Circle (miss those theaters, always found great films to pass a rain day with there).

See more

Read all reviews

Read More

Read Less

WRITE A REVIEW

EDIT REVIEW

POST RATING

Doug Archibald

Director

Kristin Archibald

Krystal

Doug Archibald

Donny

Lucas Neff

Andy

Angela Trimbur

Randi

Artemis Pebdani

Linda

I Love You Both: Trailer 1

2:11

Now Playing

View more videos

View more photos

Synopsis

Krystal and her twin brother have been codependent their entire lives, still living together in their late 20s in a one-bedroom house. When they both meet and start dating the same guy, they remain in denial about the situation until he picks only one of them, forcing them to confront that they can no longer live the same life. With nowhere to turn for advice, the twins are finally forced to look within for answers.

Director: Doug Archibald
Producer: Doug Archibald, Ryan Finnerty, Paul Holman
Screenwriter: Doug Archibald, Kristin Archibald
Distributor: Magnolia Pictures
Production Co: Magnolia Pictures
Genre: Comedy, Drama, LGBTQ+
Original Language: English
Release Date (Theaters): Jun 9, 2017, Limited
Release Date (Streaming): Jun 9, 2017
Box Office (Gross USA): $4.6K
Runtime: 1h 30m

Join The Newsletter

Join The Newsletter

Cookie Settings